October 19, 2026

June 8, 2026
A Plain-English Guide to Mareva Injunctions in Malaysia
Winning a court case is one thing. Actually recovering the money you are owed is another. One of the more frustrating situations a business can face […]
November 21, 2026

AI and Retrenchment: What Employers Need to Know in Malaysia
1 min read
Employers in Malaysia can lawfully retrench an employee because AI or automation has reduced the need for their role – but AI does not, by itself, supply the legal justification. It only supplies the commercial reason. The employer must still prove, with cogent evidence, that the role genuinely became surplus, that the affected employee was selected using fair and objective criteria, and that the retrenchment followed a documented, fair process. Get any one of these three wrong, and a plausible AI story will not save the dismissal.
Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei warned in January 2026 that AI could cause an “unusually painful” disruption to the labour market – not by replacing one occupation, but by substituting for human cognitive labour across multiple industries at once. What that looks like in practice is worth studying before assuming it works cleanly. Reuters reported that Meta ran an internal restructuring plan, code-named “Project OT,” that explored replacing much of the work performed by thousands of employees with AI agents and cutting the size of some teams by as much as 60% – before the company abandoned the most aggressive parts of the plan when the technology did not deliver as expected.
That is the risk Malaysian employers should take from the story: a restructuring plan built on an assumption about what AI can do is not evidence that it has already done so. Crucially, it is the latter, not the former, that an Industrial Court will expect.
In Ng Chang Seng v Technip Geoproduction (M) Sdn Bhd & Anor [2021] 1 MLJ 447, the Court of Appeal observed, in setting out the general principles applicable to retrenchment, that an excess of staff may result from technological developments, including computerisation, artificial intelligence, robotics, and information technology (at [9]). This sits within the wider principle that an employer has the managerial prerogative to organise and restructure its business.
In East Asiatic Company (M) Bhd v Valen Noel Yap [1987] 1 ILR 363; [1987] 1 MELR 229, the employer’s right to reorganise for reasons of economy or convenience was recognised. Similarly, in William Jacks & Co (M) Sdn Bhd v S Balasingam [1997] 3 CLJ 235; [2000] 7 MLJ 1, the Court of Appeal held that so long as managerial power is exercised bona fide, the decision is immune from examination even by the Industrial Court – but added that the Industrial Court is empowered, and indeed duty-bound, to investigate whether that power was in fact exercised bona fide.
An employer does not necessarily have to preserve a particular job merely because the work was historically performed by an employee. A business may legitimately introduce technology, reorganise its operations, or redesign its workforce. However, there is an important distinction between introducing AI and AI actually creating redundancy.
An employer contemplating an AI-driven retrenchment should therefore consider: what functions did the employee previously perform, which of those functions are now performed by AI or automation, has the amount of human labour required genuinely decreased, has the position itself disappeared or merely changed, and has the work simply been handed to a new or replacement hire. The key issue is whether technological change has actually resulted in surplus labour. Redundancy does not require the work itself to disappear: the Court of Appeal in Yap Chin Wah v Mahkamah Perusahaan Malaysia & Anor [2025] MLJU 2434 confirmed that where the work continues but requires fewer employees to carry it out, a genuine redundancy may arise. AI may provide the commercial reason for restructuring, but the employer must still establish that the restructuring genuinely affected the need for the particular role.
A redundancy exercise should concern the position, rather than being directed at a particular employee. As the Court of Appeal emphasised in Ng Chang Seng, retrenchment cannot be used as a short cut to get rid of employees for reasons such as perceived poor performance or insubordination. Where performance is the real concern, the employee should first be given an opportunity to improve and to respond, for example through warning and show-cause letters (American Malaysian Life Assurance Sdn Bhd v Sivanasan Kanagasabai [1997] 1 MELR 863).
An employer should be cautious about characterising a termination as “AI-driven redundancy” where substantially the same work continues to be done by the same number of people after the employee leaves. Questions may arise, for example, if the supposedly redundant position is filled shortly afterwards, a new or replacement hire takes over the affected employee’s duties, the same position is advertised under a different title, or the real concern appears to be the employee’s performance or conduct rather than the disappearance of the role. In Ananthi a/p Krishnasami Maistry v Widad Education Sdn Bhd [2024] ILJU 288, the employer’s failure to establish genuine redundancy and demonstrate efforts to avoid retrenchment contributed to a finding that the termination was mala fide.
For an AI-related restructuring, contemporaneous documentation will often be decisive. Employers should retain organisation charts before and after restructuring, existing and revised job descriptions, internal restructuring proposals, management papers relating to the introduction of AI or automation, workflow analyses showing which functions have been automated, and records of manpower requirements before and after implementation. Ultimately, the employer should be able to answer one straightforward question: what changed in the business, and how did that change make this particular role surplus to requirements?
A common misconception is that an employer may only retrench employees when the business is suffering financial losses. As the law stands today, that is not necessarily the case. Redundancy may also arise from legitimate commercial decisions involving technological change, restructuring, operational efficiency, consolidation of functions, or changes to the business model.
Whatever reason is relied upon, however, must be genuine and capable of being established by evidence. In How Zheng Hong v AirAsia Bhd & Anor [2026] MLJU 2329, the Court of Appeal reaffirmed that the burden lies on the employer to establish that retrenchment was carried out with just cause or excuse. Where financial hardship was relied upon, the financial position of the actual employer had to be established, rather than merely relying on the position of another company within the corporate group. The Federal Court has since granted AirAsia leave to appeal (29 September 2026), so this position may yet be revisited.
The same lesson applies to an AI-related retrenchment. If an employer says AI has reduced its manpower requirements, it should be prepared to demonstrate how the technology changed its own operations, and why fewer employees are consequently required.
Before resorting to compulsory retrenchment, employers should consider whether the impact on employees can reasonably be avoided or reduced. The Code of Conduct for Industrial Harmony 1975 remains an important guideline here, and contemplates measures aimed at avoiding or minimising workforce reductions – limiting recruitment, restricting overtime and rest-day work, reducing shifts or working hours, and retraining or transferring employees to other work. If retrenchment nevertheless becomes necessary, the Code then contemplates voluntary retrenchment and retirement schemes.
This issue is particularly important where AI changes a job rather than eliminating it outright. An AI system may automate document preparation, data entry, or routine analysis while leaving judgment, client interaction, supervision, or other functions to employees. In such circumstances, the employer should consider whether the affected employee can reasonably be retrained, reskilled, transferred, or redeployed into another suitable available role. This does not mean an employer must invent a new position solely to preserve employment – but evidence that reasonable alternatives were genuinely considered helps demonstrate that compulsory retrenchment was not arbitrary.
Establishing genuine redundancy does not end the inquiry. Where several employees perform the same or similar work, the employer must also determine who should be selected for retrenchment, and that selection should generally be based on fair and objectively defensible criteria.
The Last-In-First-Out (LIFO) principle – under which the employee with the shortest period of service within the relevant category is ordinarily considered first – is recognised in Ng Chang Seng and Dynacraft Industries Sdn Bhd v Kamaruddin bin Kana Mohd Sharif & Ors [2012] 9 CLJ 21, with any departure requiring valid and cogent reasons. That does not mean seniority must invariably override every other consideration: in a technologically transformed business, an employer may genuinely require skills that some employees possess and others do not, and there may be legitimate reasons to retain employees with the specialist qualifications or experience needed to operate redesigned systems.
Employers should nonetheless be wary of broad, undefined labels such as “AI-ready,” “future fit,” “digitally minded,” or “more adaptable.” Unless such criteria are clearly defined and objectively assessed, they collapse into subjectivity – which is exactly what went wrong in Wong Zi Chuang v AirAsia X Berhad [2025] 1 ILJ 1, where the Industrial Court criticised an internal merit and demerit system that lacked transparency and was inconsistently applied. Where an employer wants to retain someone for post-AI operating skills, it should identify measurable considerations – relevant qualifications, experience with particular systems, demonstrated competencies for the remaining role – rather than a vibe. The practical test: can the company objectively explain why Employee A was retained while Employee B was retrenched?
A defensible redundancy exercise is planned before termination decisions are communicated, not reconstructed afterward. The employer should first identify and document the genuine business reason for the restructuring, and explain how AI, automation, or other technological developments affected its manpower requirements. It should then identify which functions have disappeared or reduced, and which positions have consequently become surplus.
Once genuine redundancy is identified, the employer should consider whether retraining, redeployment, transfer, or voluntary measures could reasonably avoid or reduce compulsory retrenchment. Where only some employees performing comparable functions are affected, the employer should identify the correct selection pool and apply objective selection criteria consistently, with any departure from LIFO properly documented. Affected employees should be appropriately informed of the restructuring and its impact on their roles, and where representations or alternatives are raised, these should be genuinely considered rather than treated as a formality.
Fong Wai Ming v Malindo Airways Sdn Bhd [2025] ILJU 561 shows what happens when this is skipped: the Industrial Court identified deficiencies including the absence of meaningful consultation, the lack of an objective selection matrix, failure to justify departure from LIFO, and failure to offer meaningful alternatives. Employers should also ensure compliance with the applicable statutory, contractual, and administrative requirements relating to retrenchment, including notifying the nearest Labour Department in Borang PK at least 30 days before the retrenchment, giving the required termination notice, and paying any applicable termination benefits.
If an employee challenges the dismissal, the employer must establish that the retrenchment was supported by just cause or excuse. A useful framework is found in Lilly Industries (M) Sdn Bhd v Billy Wayne Selsor [2006] 2 MELR 215; [2006] 3 ILR 1507 (followed by the Court of Appeal in Ng Chang Seng), subsequently cited in Nurul Syazwani bt Johari v Convention & Exhibition (Putrajaya) Sdn Bhd [2026] 2 ILJ 23: the employer must establish that genuine redundancy existed, that the correct employee was selected using objective criteria, and that a fair procedure was adopted before retrenchment. The standard of proof is the balance of probabilities (Woo Vain Chan v Malayawata Steel Bhd [2016] 2 MLJ 848). These are the three pillars of a defensible retrenchment exercise – genuine redundancy, fair selection, and fair procedure – and all three have to hold, not just the one that happens to be easiest to argue.
AI may provide the commercial reason for restructuring, but the legality of the resulting retrenchment continues to depend on the same three pillars it always has. Before treating “AI reduced the need for this role” as sufficient on its own, employers should:
Employers considering an AI-driven restructuring in Malaysia, or reviewing whether an existing plan would withstand a challenge, are welcome to contact Aqran & Partners to discuss the specific facts of their situation.
Raja Nadhil Aqran is the Managing Partner of Aqran & Partners in Kuala Lumpur, advising clients on commercial litigation, corporate advisory, ESG, and compliance matters across Malaysia and the wider region. His work includes advising employers on employment disputes and retrenchment exercises.
Hafiiz Rashid is an Associate at Aqran & Partners. Focusing on non-contentious matters, he has gained significant experience in corporate restructurings (including share deals and asset deals), employment, and other matters. He advises on the employment aspects of corporate restructurings, including workforce reductions and retrenchment.
Cheow Kai Yang, an intern at the firm, contributed meaningfully to the research behind this article, and his input deserves particular recognition.
Written by

June 8, 2026
Winning a court case is one thing. Actually recovering the money you are owed is another. One of the more frustrating situations a business can face […]

December 28, 2025
Introduction – why this matters to international users of Malaysian arbitration The new AIAC Arbitration Rules 2026 will enter into force on 1 January 2026 and […]
November 21, 2026
October 16, 2026